








|
|
Liz Phair
Details, August 1998
"Sex and Candy"
by Pat Blashill
Liz Phair will play some dates on this summer's Lilith Fair tour, but unlike
Natalie and Sarah, she won't be baring her soul or communing with her inner
unicorn. Ever since Phair named her 1993 indie-rock masterpiece Exile in
Guyville as a goof on the Rolling Stones' Exile on Main Street,
she's made a career out of writing deconstructed pop songs with lyrics that
would make most pickup artists blush. Her third album,
Whitechocolatespaceegg, has a few homemade new-wave songs and vestigial
ties to lo-fi rock, but it's sincere as well as sarcastic, mostly because Phair
isn't an alt-rock club kid anymore - she's a wife and young mother. She still
writes in the hedonistic, gimme-gimme voice of a horny twenty-something, but
she's singing more about getting love than getting laid.
True love - especially the everyday and aggravating sort of love - is the
subject of eight songs, which easily outnumber her tunes about the birds and
the bees (five), headaches (three), trains (two), babies (one), and the
importance of "Shitloads of Money" (one). That's more sex, more trains, fewer
children, and less love than there is on the new album from rock's other foxy
mama, Madonna. But like the Material Girl, Phair isn't really writing about
her own life, her own son, or Mr. Phair, although pop psychology majors will
have a field day with "Johnny Feelgood." The propulsive song spins through the
pleasures of a bossy boyfriend, but it's actually about the joy of knowing
exactly what winds your clock. Phair has gone from writing about the
imperfection of desire to singing about the white lies we tell ourselves in the
pursuit of love and happiness.
Whitechocolatespaceegg isn't as ambitious as Exile. Its pure
pop pleasures lie in the way Phair folds witty lyrics into shimmering waves of
guitar that mean exactly what she says. She arranges her giddy songs so
ingeniously that their left-field hooks are all knockouts, especially the
ecstatic riff at the end of "Polyester Bride." The jangly "Love Is Nothing"
begins like on of the pickup bar scenarios on Whip-smart, Phair's flawed
second album, but it's saved by a sunny bridge and Phair's lyrical realization
that a boy at home is worth two in the bar. And since she's singing less
self-consciously and more sweetly, "Girls' Room" may be the most lovely song
she's ever recorded. It's about leaving adulthood behind for a dreamy night
out with the girls.
"Girls' Room" is the most personal song on the album; elsewhere, Phair sings
from the perspective of a fictional character. Like several of the album's
songs, "Big Tall Man" is written in the voice of a guy. After reciting a list
of simple summer pleasures like "sand and the beach," Phair drawls "I
can be a complicated communicator," then launches into a joyful, dizzy
whirl of power pop.
With Whitechocolatespaceegg, Phair has become less a confessor, like
Joni Mitchell, and more of a storyteller. She's joined the ranks of
songwriters like Elvis Costello, and Exene Cervenka and John Doe of X, and
improved upon Exile in Guyville by finding ways to express everything
from mindless happiness to the complex follies of adulthood through the eyes of
her fellow man. Phair speaks with so many voices, she could even have taken
another shot at the Stones. She could have called this one Some Boys.
|